BTC $63,938.96 -1.51%
ETH $1,791.78 -1.58%
BNB $589.42 -0.33%
XRP $0.9874 +1.78%
SOL $74.29 +1.10%
TRX $0.3096 +1.11%
DOGE $0.0592 -0.09%
ADA $0.1540 -0.18%
BCH $208.75 -1.77%
LINK $9.13 -1.86%
HYPE $68.45 -1.15%
AAVE $110.13 -2.46%
SUI $0.7259 -1.08%
XLM $0.1409 +0.62%
ZEC $932.22 -1.43%
AAPL $351.55 -0.17%
AMZN $260.20 +0.46%
GOOGL $283.24 +0.24%
MSFT $505.89 -1.82%
META $618.77 -0.41%
NVDA $160.27 +1.93%
TSLA $383.84 +0.59%
SNDK $814.90 -0.13%
INTC $55.59 +1.41%
SPCX $142.66 +3.41%
MU $727.01 -0.20%
AMD $514.04 +0.30%
BTC $63,938.96 -1.51%
ETH $1,791.78 -1.58%
BNB $589.42 -0.33%
XRP $0.9874 +1.78%
SOL $74.29 +1.10%
TRX $0.3096 +1.11%
DOGE $0.0592 -0.09%
ADA $0.1540 -0.18%
BCH $208.75 -1.77%
LINK $9.13 -1.86%
HYPE $68.45 -1.15%
AAVE $110.13 -2.46%
SUI $0.7259 -1.08%
XLM $0.1409 +0.62%
ZEC $932.22 -1.43%
AAPL $351.55 -0.17%
AMZN $260.20 +0.46%
GOOGL $283.24 +0.24%
MSFT $505.89 -1.82%
META $618.77 -0.41%
NVDA $160.27 +1.93%
TSLA $383.84 +0.59%
SNDK $814.90 -0.13%
INTC $55.59 +1.41%
SPCX $142.66 +3.41%
MU $727.01 -0.20%
AMD $514.04 +0.30%

Vitalik: The quality of the underlying proof system of L2 networks is equally important and should gradually enter the second stage as it develops

2025-05-05 14:41:51

ChainCatcher news, in response to community member Daniel Wang's proposed naming label #BattleTested for the L2 network Stage 2, Ethereum co-founder Vitalik posted on the X platform stating: "This is a good reminder: the second stage is not the only factor affecting security; the quality of the underlying proof system is equally important. This is a simplified mathematical model that shows when to enter the second stage:

Each security council member has a 10% independent 'break' chance; we consider activity failure (refusal to sign or key unavailability) and security failure (signing the wrong thing or key being hacked) as equally likely; the goal: to minimize the likelihood of protocol collapse under the above assumptions.

Stage 0 security council is 4/7, Stage 1 is 6/8; please note that these assumptions are very imperfect. In reality, council members have 'common mode failures': they may collude, or all be coerced or hacked in the same way, etc. This makes both Stage 0 and Stage 1 more insecure than shown in the model, so entering Stage 2 earlier than the model suggests is the best choice.

Additionally, note that by turning the proof system itself into multiple independent systems via multi-signature, the probability of proof system collapse can be greatly reduced (this is what I advocated in previous proposals). I suspect that all Stage 2 deployments in the past few years will be like this. Considering this, here is the chart. The X-axis is the probability of proof system collapse. The Y-axis is the probability of protocol collapse. As the quality of the proof system improves, the optimal stage shifts from Stage 0 to Stage 1, and then from Stage 1 to Stage 2. Using a proof system of Stage 0 quality for Stage 2 is the worst.

In short, @l2beat ideally should showcase proof system audits and maturity metrics (preferably proof system implementations rather than the entire aggregation, so we can reuse them) and stages."

Vitalik: The quality of the underlying proof system of L2 networks is equally important and should gradually enter the second stage as it develops

链捕手ChainCatcher напоминает: относитесь к блокчейну рационально, повышайте осведомлённость о рисках и будьте осторожны с выпуском и спекуляциями виртуальными токенами. Весь контент на сайте является рыночной информацией или мнением соответствующих сторон и не является инвестиционной рекомендацией в любой форме. Если вы обнаружите чувствительную информацию, нажмите — мы оперативно разберёмся.

Упомянутые проекты
app_icon
ChainCatcher Building the Web3 world with innovations.